Visiting CMU: Historical Home of CS1-for-All

March 21, 2011 at 7:16 am 4 comments

It’s Spring Break at Georgia Tech this week.  Last week was crammed full of midterm grading. Now that it’s Spring, I’m traveling north to colder climates.

Today, I’m at Carnegie Mellon University to speak in their Program for Interdisciplinary Education Research (PIER) today, and at the “EdBag” tomorrow.  I’m excited (and a bit nervous) — I’ve never spoken here at CMU before.  Leigh Ann Sudol-DeLyser is my student host, and she gave me a great tour of the campus yesterday.  For today’s talk, I’m giving a variation of my “Meeting the Computing Needs for Everyone” talk (describing Brian Dorn’s work and the role of contextualized computing education in this goal), but with special attention to the Alan Perlis lecture from 1961.

I re-read that chapter again yesterday.  Wow — it’s really clear that the idea of teaching everyone an introductory course on CS has its home here, at the University that grew out of Carnegie Tech.  While I had remembered that Peter Elias of MIT had pushed back against the idea of such a course as being unnecessary, I hadn’t remembered how J.C.R. Licklider and Perlis responded.

  • Elias argues that programming is just a “mental chore” that the computer should be able to take care of for us: “If the computers, together with sufficiently ingenious languages and programming systems, are capable of doing everything that Professor Perlis describes—and I believe they are (and more)—then they should be ingenious enough to do it without the human symbiote being obliged to perform the mechanical chores which are a huge part of current programming effort, and which are a large part of what must now be taught in the introductory course that he proposes.”
  • Licklider emphasizes what might be possible with this new kind of language. “Peter, I think the first apes who tried to talk with one another decided that learning language was a dreadful bore…But some people write poetry in the language we speak.”
  • Perlis makes a really interesting pedagogical rebuttal. He says that what he really wants to teach are abstractions, and a course in programming is the best way he can think of doing that. He also says (not quoted below) that he has no evidence for this, but believes it strongly. “The purpose of a course in programming is to teach people how to construct and analyze processes…A course in programming is concerned with abstraction: the abstraction of constructing, analyzing, and describing processes…The point is to make the students construct complex processes out of simpler ones….A properly designed programming course will develop these abilities better than any other course.”
  • John McCarthy (father of Lisp) also responded in opposition to Elias. “Programming is the art of stating procedures. Prior to the development of digital computers, one did not have to state procedures precisely, and no languages were developed for stating procedures precisely. Now we have a tool that will carry out any procedure, provided we can state this procedure sufficiently well. It is utopian to suppose that either English or some combination of English and mathematics will turn out to be the appropriate language for stating procedures.”  Interesting how McCarthy and Licklider, as in Donald Knuth’s Turing award lecture, talk about programming as art.

Leigh Ann told me that the “EdBag” is a place to play with new and incomplete ideas.  I’m planning to talk about the challenge of producing more high school CS teachers, including alternatives like Dave Patterson’s proposal.  I’ve been thinking a lot about using a worked examples approach, informed by Ashok Goel’s structure-behavior-function model of design cognition.

Tomorrow, I fly to DC and spend two days reviewing NSF proposals.  Still trying to get the rest of my proposals read today, and all the reviews written tonight.  Thursday night, I’ll get back home to Atlanta where it really is Spring already.

Entry filed under: Uncategorized. Tags: , , , .

White House Launches New Tally of STEM Education Programs – ScienceInsider A Definition of Computational Thinking from Jeannette Wing

4 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Alan Kay  |  March 21, 2011 at 8:32 am

    Thanks Mark

    This substance can never be emphasized too much (along with the idea — which Al Perlis definitely understood, but gets lost all the time — that you don’t get the benefits from these ideas unless they are taught in special ways (and very differently than most approaches to CSD1).

    Another important part of the Carnegie Legacy that you should mention is what they use to call “the immigration course” for new grad students (who would show up 6 weeks early and be taught mini-courses by the faculty and existing grad students which covered “what grad school there was all about”).

    These courses were gems of succinct introduction, and besides the excellent content, the new grad students wound up meeting most of the existing profs and grad students.

    I’ve often wondered if perhaps the first targets of President Obama’s call for “learning software as effective as personal tutors” should be the HS equivalent of those CMU immigration courses for understanding the metes and bounds of Computing.



  • […] 26, 2011 When I visited Carnegie Mellon University a few weeks ago, I got to spend some time talking with Ken Koedinger and Albert Corbett about the early cognitive […]

  • […] have advocated for some years now “Computing for Everyone,” that Alan Perlis had it right when he argued in 1961 that everyone on campus should learn to program.  Perlis […]

  • […] computer, including being many other computers with many processes. That’s the big idea that Alan Perlis was talking about in 1961 when he talked about computer science as the study of process. That’s one of the big ideas behind object-oriented programming as Alan Kay defined it.  We […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

Recent Posts

March 2011
« Feb   Apr »


Blog Stats

  • 1,519,383 hits

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 5,276 other followers

CS Teaching Tips

%d bloggers like this: